Find millimeter on Facebook

Related Articles


Leitner's Cinematography Corner, No. 5

Nov 6, 2009 12:00 PM, By D.W. Leitner

EX3 x 2 = DIY 3D

      Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines  

High-angle shot from Manhatta (1921)

High-angle shot from Manhatta (1921)

No, I'd argue the answer is instead found at the Newark Museum in Newark, New Jersey, where two remarkable local filmmakers using nothing more than a pair of Sony PMW-EX3s and Apple Final Cut Pro have created a remarkable 6-minute paean to the city of Newark—in flawless 3D.

The Newark Museum commissioned the filmmaking team of director/producer Marylou Tibaldo-Bongiorno and cinematographer/editor Jerome Bongiorno to make New Work: Newark in 3D in celebration of the museum's centennial. The Bongiornos decided to model their film after one of the first experimental films made in America, Manhatta (1921), a silent black-and-white salute to the urban dynamism of New York City by painter Charles Sheeler and photographer Paul Strand, with stirring intertitles lifted from Walt Whitman.

At 65 shots in 11 minutes, Manhatta depicts the brawn and bustle of Manhattan's harbor and streets from dawn to dusk, prefiguring better known "city symphony" films such as Walter Ruttmann's Berlin, Symphony of a Great City, or Dziga Vertov's Man with a Movie Camera by almost a decade.

Like Manhatta, Newark in 3D constructs visual rhythm and poetry from stunning B&W, high- and low-angled shots of Newark's built environment—statues, bridges, waterways, cathedrals, skyscrapers—as well as its river of people and their activities. In homage to the original film, the Bongiornos have assembled about the same number of shots as Manhatta, featuring structures and locations 100 years old, the same age as the museum.

Jerome Biongiorno on a fireboat with dual Sony PMW-EX3s. Image courtesy of Bongiorno Productions Inc.

Jerome Biongiorno on a fireboat with dual Sony PMW-EX3s.
Image courtesy of Bongiorno Productions Inc.

Three things make Newark in 3D outstanding.

Jerome Bongiorno's 3D cinematography is masterful. On his jam-synced EX3s, he matched focus, iris, gain, framing, and focal length (using the viewfinder zoom scale from Z0 wide to Z99 telephoto). He worked out a system to determine the ideal interaxial distance, what he calls "stereo base," between EX3s, given the subject of each shot and its distance. Later, in Final Cut Studio, he tweaked, as need be, image size and position to obtain the best stereo effect.

If Jerome's powerful images appear Whitmanesque in exuberance, the effect is underscored by local poet Jon Curley's ardently syncopated verses (read by the poet himself). I watched Newark in 3D three times, and the Curley's rhymed cadences dug in deeper with each listen.

The museum's 3D installation is exemplary. Newark in 3D is projected, continuously looped, in a dedicated black-box gallery. The screen occupies an entire wall, from floor to ceiling. This gives the illusion that the fourth wall has simply vanished, and that, from wherever we stand (there are no chairs), we are gazing directly into 3D space, albeit black and white. If the ceiling is 9ft. tall, then the screen is 12ft. wide because the picture aspect ratio is 1.33, matching that of the original Manhatta, which, incidentally, also loops continuously on an LCD screen adjacent to the screening room.

Although cropped to 1.33, original images were captured at 1920x1080 in Sony's MPEG-2 XDCAM EX format at 35Mbps, edited in Final Cut Studio, and played to screen from a server. (Deliverables were files, not physical media. The times, they are a changin'.)

I admit to not being a fan of the anaglyphic separation used (requiring glasses with red and cyan filters), although I understand the lure of its simplicity compared to polarization or use of LCD shutter glasses.

Still, I wonder if Cameron's Avatar, produced with no expense spared, will measure up to the success of Newark in 3D, if only as art.

New Work: Newark in 3D runs continuously through Jan. 10, 2010, at the Newark Museum in Newark, New Jersey.

To learn more about the production and installation of New Work: Newark in 3D:

Share this article

Continue the discussion on Crosstalk the Millimeter Forum.

© 2015 NewBay Media, LLC.

Browse Back Issues
Back to Top